Colonial Inn is housed in a Victorian-style building with a wraparound porch, located at 305 Main St in Big Indian, New York. The inn offers a homey, antiquated atmosphere featuring numerous historical objects and decor that reflect its long history dating back to 1790. Guests can expect modest, comfortable rooms where original wood floors creak, providing a sense of authenticity rather than modern luxury.
The property includes a cozy restaurant and bar serving a variety of drinks, with a reputation for friendly hospitality from the owners and staff. Breakfast is provided free of charge each morning, with offerings such as French toast and bacon highlighted by previous visitors. While the inn does not have a pool or fitness center, it does provide free Wi-Fi, parking, and is both pet- and kid-friendly, catering well to relaxed, informal stays.
Situated about a mile from Belleayre Beach and three miles from Belleayre Mountain Ski Area, the inn serves as a practical base for exploring outdoor activities such as skiing, snowboarding, and hiking nearby peaks like Panther Mountain and Balsam Mountain. The surrounding wooded mountains contribute to a peaceful rural setting that appeals to guests looking for an escape from busy urban life.
Guest feedback often highlights the warm, welcoming service and unique character of the inn, describing it as a nostalgic retreat with quirks and antiques that may not suit those expecting contemporary accommodations. Some note that the rooms could benefit from updates, but overall, the Colonial Inn is recommended for travelers seeking a down-to-earth experience with a sense of local history and charm.
Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.